Sherlock vs Hacken vs Cyfrin: Smart Contract Audits Compared

Quick answer. Sherlock sells private Collaborative Audits, AI-assisted Audit Engine reviews and post-launch bounties. Hacken sells quote-based private audits with the broadest published stack list. Cyfrin pairs private audits with CodeHawks competitive audits and a dated public report index. Their pricing is not comparable.
Video transcript
Sherlock, Hacken and Cyfrin all sell smart contract audits through different models. The model decides who reviews your code, and what happens after.
Sherlock offers private Collaborative Audits, an AI-assisted Audit Engine and bounties. Hacken sells quote-based private audits. Cyfrin pairs private audits with CodeHawks competitive audits.
Hacken publishes a typical range of three thousand to over one hundred thousand dollars. Sherlock publishes no price of its own; its market history spans five thousand to two hundred fifty thousand dollars. We found no public Cyfrin rate card.
Hacken's portfolio showed 2,208 audits, by its own count. Cyfrin keeps a dated GitHub index with severity counts. Sherlock publishes reports with client permission.
Scope, severity labels and disclosure rules differ, so totals are not a quality score. Open three reports on code like yours from each firm.
Coverage after the audit differs. Sherlock offers a post-launch bounty and optional Shield cover, without guaranteed payment. Hacken verifies fixes and offers optional DualDefense. Cyfrin's CodeHawks describes a post-fix review, but no standing post-launch program was confirmed.
Send all three the same questions. Confirm the engagement type, the named reviewers and their reports on your stack. Freeze one commit, and agree fix-review rounds and cover for later changes.
Read the full comparison, or share your repository and commit with Guardian for a scoped audit quote.
Why This Choice Matters
Sherlock, Hacken and Cyfrin all sell smart contract audits. They sell them through different models, and the model decides who reviews your code and what happens after.
This comparison uses the firms' own pages, docs and report repositories, plus two third-party listings where those are silent. Guardian publishes this page and sells smart contract audits, so it is not a neutral party.
Product names and prices change, so confirm each in writing.
Our top smart contract auditors ranking scores ten firms on one points scheme. This page goes deeper on three, head to head.
The Three Models
Sherlock offers the most models of the three. Its docs, updated October 2026, list private Collaborative Audits, Audit Engine, bug bounties and lifecycle security. Sherlock
In a Collaborative Audit, a selected team of researchers reviews the code together. Audit Engine coordinates AI auditors, frontier models and human researchers in one review.
Sherlock's docs say Audit Engine replaces audit contests. It offers an AI-only pass in as little as two days, and contest-style runs with human researchers.
Judged results normally arrive within 24 to 48 hours, from an AI judge with expert Lead Judge review.
Hacken is mainly a private, quote-based audit firm. Its methodology, version 3.0 of June 16, 2026, has a team of auditors review the code line by line at the same time, for double coverage. Hacken
Automated analysis, fuzzing and invariant testing sit beside the manual review. An independent QA auditor then checks the work before the report.
DualDefense is Hacken's optional crowdsourced layer, run after the main audit. Its service page says it comes at no extra cost; confirm that in the quote.
Cyfrin runs both models. Its GitHub index lists reports from engagements conducted by the Cyfrin team. Cyfrin
CodeHawks, Cyfrin's competitive platform, runs public audits where many auditors compete. Its private format has a selected auditor or team review the code. Cyfrin CodeHawks
After submissions close, community judging runs first, then lead judging. CodeHawks says judging averages about three weeks, so plan it into the launch date.
A third-party directory's newest listed CodeHawks contest ran July 9 to 16, 2026. No active contest was confirmed in November. Smart Contract Hacking
Sherlock vs Hacken vs Cyfrin
Hacken publishes the longest language list: Solidity, Rust, Move, Go, C#, C++, Java, Python, Cairo, Scrypto, Swift and Daml. Hacken
Its listed ecosystems include Ethereum, Solana, Sui, Aptos, Arbitrum, Cosmos, Polkadot, StarkNet and Canton Network.
Cyfrin's index tags work on EVM, Solana, Stellar, Rust, Substrate, Cosmos and formal verification. That shows disclosed work, not current capacity for your scope. Cyfrin
Sherlock says it audits across languages and execution environments, without a list in its introduction. Sherlock
| Factor | Sherlock | Hacken | Cyfrin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Model | Collaborative Audits, Audit Engine, bounties | Private, quote-based audits; optional DualDefense | Private audits plus CodeHawks contests |
| Stated method | Selected researcher team; AI plus humans in Audit Engine | Double manual review, fuzzing, invariants, QA review | Team audits; contests judged in two phases |
| Public reports | GitHub repo, published with client permission | 2,208 audits, by its count | Dated GitHub index, some rows redacted |
| Severity data | No normalized total published | 17,447 vulnerabilities found, by its count | C, H, M, L, I and G counts per row |
| Stacks | Across languages and execution environments | 12 languages, Solidity to Daml | EVM, Solana, Stellar, Substrate, Cosmos tags |
| Pricing signal | No own price; market history $5,000 to $250,000 | Typically $3,000 to $100,000+ | No public rate card found |
| Timing signal | AI-only pass in as little as two days | 5 business days to 6 weeks, by scope | Set at onboarding; contest judging averages about three weeks |
| After the audit | Post-launch bounty; optional Shield cover, up to $500,000 | Fix verification; optional DualDefense | Mitigation phase and post-fix review; post-launch cover not confirmed |
What the Report Libraries Show
Sherlock publishes audit and coverage reports on GitHub, with each protocol team's permission. The repository lists 2026 engagements but gives no current total. Sherlock
Hacken's portfolio page showed 2,208 audits of 1,190 companies on November 17, 2026, with 17,447 vulnerabilities found. These are Hacken's own totals. Hacken
Cyfrin's index gives each report a date, technology tags and counts for Critical, High, Medium, Low, Informational and Gas findings. The latest entries end November 12, 2026. Cyfrin
About 300 rows appear, and some are redacted, so it is not a full client list. Some rows, such as MetaMask Connect, are tagged Off-Chain, Web2Sec and Pentest.
The three libraries cannot be ranked against each other. Scope, severity labels and disclosure rules differ by firm.
Instead, open three reports on code like yours from each firm. Our guide on how to read a smart contract audit report shows what to check in each.
Pricing Signals
Hacken publishes a typical range of $3,000 to $100,000 or more. Scope, complexity, integrations and timeline set the quote. Hacken
Its timing signal is 5 to 10 business days for simple contracts, 2 to 4 weeks for most audits and 4 to 6 weeks for complex protocols.
Sherlock publishes no price for its own audits and quotes per scope. Its market reference, updated November 13, 2026, spans $5,000 to $250,000 per engagement, with most DeFi protocol audits at $25,000 to $100,000. Sherlock, Guardix
Remediation passes typically add $5,000 to $20,000 each. Sherlock says these ranges come from 2025 and early 2026 quotes, so they are market history, not a current quote.
We found no numeric Cyfrin rate card in its public sources. CodeHawks cites low platform fees but publishes no figure. Cyfrin CodeHawks
A third-party comparison updated October 19, 2026 says Cyfrin publishes no audit price and estimates turnaround per codebase during onboarding.
Get every quote on the same frozen commit, with fix rounds included. Our guide to smart contract audit pricing models explains fixed-fee, auditor-week and contest pricing.
After-Audit Coverage
Sherlock offers a post-launch bounty to qualifying customers it has audited. A researcher who knows the codebase reviews and explains each report at no charge. Sherlock
Disputes can go to Sherlock's claims committee and UMA's Optimistic Oracle. The platform fee is 10% of the fees paid to researchers for valid findings.
Sherlock Shield can add exploit payout cover of up to $500,000 for code that completes a Sherlock audit and fix review. It is not included by default, and Sherlock says it does not guarantee payment.
Hacken gives clients 10 business days to fix findings. Its auditors then verify the fixes, check for new issues and issue the final report. Hacken
DualDefense can add crowdsourced testing after fixes or upgrades, or before launch, listings and outside due diligence.
Hacken's DualDefense page describes a 30-day crowdsourced audit by independent bug hunters, with critical-bug rewards covered by DualDefense Flash Pools.
CodeHawks docs describe a mitigation phase for competitive and private audits, optional mitigation review contests and a final post-fix review. Cyfrin CodeHawks
The checked sources do not show a standing post-launch program for Cyfrin. Cyfrin
With any firm, code changed after the reviewed commit is unreviewed. Our bug bounty vs smart contract audit guide covers what a live bounty adds.
Which Fits Which Team
Sherlock fits a team that wants one vendor for a private review, an AI-assisted pass and a bounty after launch. Sherlock
Hacken fits a team that wants a conventional private audit, a written method, a broad language list and a public price range. Hacken
Cyfrin fits a team that wants a competitive audit beside a private one, and a dated report index to check. Confirm a contest slot first. Cyfrin CodeHawks, Cyfrin
Novel, high-value code usually warrants a private audit first, then a contest on the fixed commit. Our audit contest vs private audit guide sets out that order.
Whichever you pick, put deployment and initialization paths in scope. In Guardian's Papertrade review, a factory initialization path relied on deployment assumptions instead of enforcing access control (Informational, resolved). Guardian Security
Send each firm the same questions. The full scorecard is in how to choose a smart contract auditor.
- Which engagement is this: private audit, AI-assisted review, contest or bounty?
- Who are the named reviewers, and which public reports have they written on our stack?
- Which files, commit, deployment scripts and exclusions are in scope?
- How many fix-review rounds are included, and do the same reviewers run them?
- Can we publish the final report, with the commit for each round?
- What covers upgrades and code we change after the audit?
Frequently Asked Questions
When are Sherlock bounty payments due?
Sherlock's docs say fees are paid in full within 10 days of the latest resolution. That can be a Sherlock judge, its claims committee or UMA's Optimistic Oracle, so budget for the slowest path. Sherlock
Which fuzzing tools does Hacken use?
Hacken's methodology names Echidna, Foundry and cargo-fuzz, chosen by language. Ask whether the fuzzing harness and invariants are handed over, so your team can rerun them on later changes. Hacken
What do protocols spend on security in a year?
Sherlock's market reference says protocols with meaningful TVL routinely run $150,000 to $500,000 a year. It draws on 2025 and early 2026 quotes, so treat it as context, not a budget. Sherlock
Does an audit from any of the three guarantee security?
No. None of the sources reviewed shows Sherlock, Hacken or Cyfrin guaranteeing security or full vulnerability coverage. Keys, signers and infrastructure sit outside a contract audit and need their own controls.
Related reading
- top smart contract auditors
- how to choose a smart contract auditor
- audit firm pricing compared
- smart contract audit rfp template
- smart contract audit scoping
Sources
- Sherlock: Introduction to Sherlock
- Sherlock: Smart Contract Audit Pricing: 2026 Market Reference and 2027 Budget Guide (February 18, 2026)
- Sherlock: Post-Launch Bounty
- Sherlock: Sherlock Audit and Coverage Reports
- Sherlock: Sherlock Contests
- Hacken: Smart Contract Audit
- Hacken: Smart Contract Code Review and Security Analysis Methodology (June 16, 2026)
- Hacken: Security Assessment Reports
- Cyfrin CodeHawks: Intro to Cyfrin CodeHawks
- Cyfrin CodeHawks: The Judging Process
- Cyfrin: Cyfrin Audit Reports
- Guardian Security: Papertrade Protocol Review: Factory Initialization Checks Not Enforced
- Guardian Security: Veranta V2 Review
- Sherlock: About Audit Engine
- Sherlock: About Audit Engine, official documentation mirror
- Guardix: Smart Contract Audit Firms Compared: Prices and Turnaround
- Smart Contract Hacking: CodeHawks Audit Contests Directory
- Sherlock: Sherlock Shield
- Hacken: DualDefense
- Cyfrin CodeHawks: The Auditing Process
- Sherlock: Audit Engine FAQ
- Sherlock: Scoping & Audit Requirements
Get a Scoped Quote on Your Commit
Guardian's smart contract audit puts two independent teams on one scope: manual review with invariant fuzzing, and Helix. Only human-verified findings reach the report, with a fix review. Share your repository and commit to scope it.