Halborn Alternatives: Audit and Pentest Firms Compared
Part of our guide to Web3 penetration testing

Quick answer. For smart contract audits, Guardian lists itself first; on our points method, Spearbit (Cantina) leads, Guardian is second, then Zellic, Quantstamp, OtterSec, Hashlock and OpenZeppelin.
For pentests, choose by need: CertiK, Hacken, NCC Group, Cure53, Kudelski Security, or Trail of Bits for wallet code.
Video transcript
Halborn sells audits, pentests and advisory. Teams looking elsewhere usually want another audit firm for their contracts, or another tester for the apps, cloud and keys around them.
Guardian publishes this guide and lists itself first. On its own points method, though, Spearbit, now on Cantina, leads and Guardian ranks second.
None of this is a verdict on Halborn's work. A switch can add a second opinion, named reviewers, and contests and bounties, which its menu does not list.
Audit firms are scored on public evidence only. Halborn scores 6 points, and every firm here scores at least that. Points measure what firms publish, not review quality.
Spearbit leads with 7 points and over 720 reviews. Guardian, Zellic, Quantstamp, OtterSec, Hashlock and OpenZeppelin each score 6, with Halborn just after.
Pick the firm that matches what you run. Pentest firms have no public index to score, so these are not ranked.
Guardian's offchain team is led by Carlos Polop, who co-founded and built HackTricks. On the Avantis V2 backend, it returned 68 findings, two Critical and six High.
To switch, hand over every Halborn report. Have the new firm retest old findings, pin the scope to a commit, and check the deployed bytecode.
Read the full guide for each firm's evidence, or talk to Guardian about audits and pentests at guardian.security.
Disclosure: Guardian publishes this guide and lists itself first, though its own points method puts it second, behind Spearbit (Cantina). Claims about other firms come from their own pages, public records or reputable reporting, checked November 18, 2026.
Halborn sells smart contract audits, pentests and advisory work to crypto teams and financial institutions.
Buyers who look elsewhere usually want one of two things: another audit firm for their contracts, or another tester for the apps, cloud and keys around them.
This guide covers both. Audit firms are ranked on public evidence; pentest firms are matched to what you need tested.
What Halborn Offers
First, Halborn on its own terms:
- Audits: smart contract assessments, Layer 1 assessments and code security audits.
- Pentests: web application and cloud infrastructure pentests, and red team exercises.
- Advisory: custody and key management, compliance readiness, technical due diligence and risk assessments.
- AI: AI security assessments, AI red teaming and AI advisory.
- Scale: 5K+ assessments, 15K findings and 800+ clients, by its count.
- Certifications: ISO 27001:2022 and SOC 2 Type 2.
Logos on its homepage include Coinbase, Circle, Ripple, Solana, Sygnum Bank, AMINA Bank and Banco Central do Brasil.
Why Teams Look Elsewhere
What a switch can add:
- A second opinion. A different team, using different methods, on the same code.
- Named reviewers. Halborn's Saucerswap Perpetuals report, from October 2026, names no engineer. It says one full-time engineer was assigned for eight business days.
- Contests and bounties. Halborn's service menu lists neither.
None of this is a verdict on Halborn's work.
How We Ranked the Audit Firms
We reused the points method from our top smart contract auditors ranking. It scores public evidence only.
| Criterion | What we checked | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Report library | Public reports in the firm's own index, rounded down to tens | 400+: 3; 250 to 399: 2; 150 to 249: 1 |
| Finding depth | Where severity totals for each report appear | In the index: 2; inside reports only: 1 |
| Stack breadth | Ecosystems in the index or reports | 4+: 2; 2 to 3: 1 |
Equal totals break on named reviewers, then fix status, offchain services, contests run now and library size.
We set the cut before rechecking any counts: every firm in that ranking that scores at least Halborn's 6 points. Counts were rechecked on November 18, 2026, and no score changed.
Points measure what firms publish, not review quality.
Audit Alternatives Ranked
| # | Firm | Points | Public reports | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Guardian | 6; listed first | 300+, severity totals in index | Contracts and offchain systems from one firm |
| 2 | Spearbit (Cantina) | 7 | 720+, severity totals in portfolio data | Knowing exactly who reviews your code |
| 3 | Zellic | 6 | 400+, no severity totals in index | Cryptography, ZK and multichain code |
| 4 | Quantstamp | 6 | 400+, no severity totals in portal | Audits, pentests and incident response |
| 5 | OtterSec | 6 | 390+, severity totals in index | Solana and Move programs |
| 6 | Hashlock | 6 | 430+ PDFs, no severity totals in index | Contracts, pentests and onchain monitoring |
| 7 | OpenZeppelin | 6 | About 400 public of 900+ | Code built on OpenZeppelin Contracts |
Halborn, for reference, scores 6: 270+ reports, with severity totals in its index. Its sample named no reviewers and its library is the smallest of the 6s, so it would follow OpenZeppelin.
Among the 6s, Guardian, Zellic, Quantstamp and OtterSec name reviewers in reports; Hashlock's and OpenZeppelin's samples did not. Fix status and offchain services do not separate those four; only Guardian runs contests now, so it ranks second.
Within each group, the larger library ranks higher: Zellic 409, Quantstamp 402 and OtterSec 395 reports; Hashlock 430+ PDFs and OpenZeppelin about 400 audits.
1. Guardian
- Choose it for: contracts and the offchain systems around them, tested by one firm
- Public work: 300+ public reports with 9,500+ findings, and severity totals for each in its index
- Method: two independent teams on one scope, one with manual review and invariant fuzzing, one running Helix, Guardian's AI auditor
Only human-verified findings reach the report. Keeper, API and backend pentests can run alongside the contracts.
Vanguard adds a $100,000 Guardian-funded contest, a hosted bug bounty and six months of update review.
2. Spearbit (Cantina)
- Choose it for: seeing exactly who will review your code
- Public work: 720+ reviews, nearly all naming their researchers
- Also runs: competitions and bug bounties
Spearbit's own site now says it lives on Cantina, which also sells AI security products. Confirm which team you are buying.
3. Zellic
- Choose it for: cryptography, ZK circuits and multichain code
- Public work: 400+ reports across EVM, Solana, Cosmos, Move, Cairo and TON
- Track record: critical or high-impact findings in 153 of its 338 reviews in 2025, by its count
Its site also lists web application and operational security reviews. Code4rena, which it bought in 2024, is winding down.
4. Quantstamp
- Choose it for: audits, pentests and incident response from one vendor
- Public work: 400+ reports in its portal, of the 1,400+ audits it counts
- Reviewers: names its auditors in reports and on its site
5. OtterSec
- Choose it for: Solana and Move programs
- Public work: 390+ reports, each with severity totals in its index
- Strength: maintains Anchor, a Solana smart contract framework, and names auditors in reports
- Consideration: only 14 public reports are dated 2026, so ask for recent work like yours
6. Hashlock
- Choose it for: contracts, pentests and onchain monitoring from one provider
- Public work: 430+ report PDFs, 40+ of them pentest reports
- Consideration: its sample report named no reviewers, so ask who will be staffed
7. OpenZeppelin
- Choose it for: code built on OpenZeppelin Contracts
- Public work: about 400 audits on its site, of the 900+ it states since 2017
- Method: at least two researchers inspect each line of code
S&P Global completed its purchase of OpenZeppelin on October 26, 2026. OpenZeppelin runs as its own unit.
Just below the line
Five firms in that ranking score 5, one point under Halborn. They are listed alphabetically, not ranked.
| Firm | Points | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| ChainSecurity | 5 | 430+ reports; three ecosystems in its index |
| Cyfrin | 5 | 200+ public summaries; full reports went private on October 30, 2026 |
| Pashov Audit Group | 5 | 310+ reports on GitHub; no severity totals in its index |
| Sherlock | 5 | 300+ reports; sells collaborative audits, contests and Audit Engine |
| Trail of Bits | 5 | 310+ blockchain reports; no severity totals in its index |
CertiK and Hacken also sell audits but are unscored: our top 10 ranking could not count CertiK's public reports, and Hacken's site blocks our reader. Certora, known for formal verification, scores 4.
Pentest Alternatives by Need
Halborn's pentests cover web apps, APIs, cloud and red teams, and its index lists backend and bridge pentests. Its pentest page offers “periodic retesting” and expert validation of fixes.
No public index lets pentest firms be scored the same way, so these are not ranked. Pick the row that matches what you run.
| What you need tested | Firm | Public evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Keepers and backends that move funds | Guardian | Avantis, GMX keeper and USDT0 Gasolina case studies |
| Wallets and key management systems | Trail of Bits | Kraken wallet, Uniswap extension and Turnkey KMS reviews |
| Exchange apps needing compliance reports | CertiK | 350+ pentests, its count; aligned to SOC 2, MiCA and DORA |
| Exchange apps and red team exercises | Hacken | Toobit, Pionex and WhiteBIT pentest reports; lists red teaming |
| Custody approvals, key systems and dApp frontends | NCC Group | “Dozens” of exchange, DeFi and custody engagements |
| Wallet apps and crypto libraries | Cure53 | ERA Wallet, Tangem Wallet and Coinbase cb-mpc reports |
| Threshold signing code | Kudelski Security | Uniwire, Lit Protocol and Ava Labs reviews |
Hacken's pentest page includes one free retest, and Kudelski Security retests resolved issues. CertiK's pentest page lists remediation steps, not a retest, though its homepage cites remediation verification on client work.
Trail of Bits sells no product called a pentest. Its services page describes “deep code, cloud, and architecture review.”
Guardian's blockchain pentests cover web apps, APIs, cloud, extensions, SDKs and keepers, and retest the fixes. Its offchain team is led by Carlos Polop, who co-founded and built HackTricks.
On the Avantis V2 backend, reviewed alongside its contracts, Guardian returned 68 findings, two Critical and six High.
Firm-by-firm pentest detail is in our best web3 pentesting firms guide.
How to Switch From Halborn
Carry Halborn's work into the new engagement.
- Read each status. Halborn's Saucerswap Perpetuals report marks all 55 findings addressed: the Critical and both Highs solved, 18 risk accepted and 23 acknowledged.
- Hand over every report. Give the new firm each open, accepted and acknowledged finding.
- Retest old pentest findings. Ask the new firm to confirm Halborn's open findings are fixed before it tests new scope.
- Re-rate severities. Halborn scores findings from 0 to 10 on its own scale, inspired by CVSS. Your new firm may use another.
- Pin the new scope. Name the commit hash and list every file changed since Halborn's last report.
- Re-review what changed. Halborn itself recommends a follow-up assessment within six months, or after any material change.
- Check what is live. Confirm the deployed bytecode matches the commit the new firm reviewed.
For what Halborn has quoted in public DAO records, see what top auditors charge.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Halborn a legitimate security firm?
Yes. Founded in 2019, Halborn raised a $90 million Series A led by Summit Partners in 2022, when it was based in Miami. Jacques Boschung became CEO in 2024. It ranks third in our best web3 pentesting firms guide.
How much does Halborn charge?
Halborn publishes no prices. Its 2024 Arbitrum DAO bid priced continuous security at $500,000 per six-month term, or $20,833 per engineer week; it was not elected. In 2023 it told Lido's forum an average infrastructure audit costs about $50,000.
Who are Halborn's main competitors?
Firms that sell audits and pentests, as Halborn does, include CertiK, Hacken, Quantstamp, Hashlock and Guardian. Hacken also sells MiCA, DORA and proof of reserves work. Spearbit (Cantina), Zellic and OtterSec lead with audits; NCC Group and Cure53 with pentests.
Is Halborn better than CertiK?
Neither is better for every system. CertiK counts 8,512 audits and runs Skynet, a security score shown in wallets. Halborn suits institutions testing contracts, custody and infrastructure together, and publishes pentest reports, such as Memora's September 2026 bridge pentest.
Which chains does Halborn audit?
Its public audits from September and October 2026 cover Solidity on EVM chains and Hedera, Rust on Solana, CosmWasm and Bitcoin, and Daml. Its smart contract page names Ethereum, Solana and Cosmos.
Does Halborn offer monitoring or incident response?
Not as a named service. Its DeFi page mentions “ongoing monitoring and incident response,” but its services menu lists neither. Quantstamp and Hashlock list both. Guardian's Managed Security runs 24/7 monitoring and response across contracts, keepers, backends and cloud.
Who founded Halborn?
Rob Behnke and Steve Walbroehl founded Halborn. Behnke is now executive chairman and president, and Walbroehl is CTO. The company describes itself as fully remote.
Sources
- Halborn: Homepage, services, statistics and certifications (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Halborn: DeFi Protocols industry page (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Halborn: Audits index, 277 audits (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Halborn: Smart Contract Assessment (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Halborn: Web Application Penetration Testing (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Halborn: Custody and Key Management Assessment (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Halborn: Saucerswap Perpetuals assessment report (October 2026, accessed November 18, 2026)
- Halborn: Blockchain Vulnerability Scoring System (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Halborn: Who We Are (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Halborn: Press releases, ISO/IEC 27001 certification (January 27, 2026) and new CEO (September 10, 2024)
- The Block: Blockchain security firm Halborn raises $90 million in Series A funding (July 19, 2022)
- Arbitrum forum: Halborn application to the Arbitrum Research and Development Collective (February 12, 2024)
- Snapshot: ARDC Security Member Election result (closed March 12, 2024)
- Lido Research Forum: Halborn, Proposal: Infrastructure Security Audit (November 20, 2023)
- Cantina: Portfolio, competitions and homepage (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Spearbit: Homepage, “Spearbit now lives on Cantina” (accessed November 18, 2026)
- GitHub: Zellic/publications, audit reports (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Zellic: Homepage, 2025 review statistics and services (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Code4rena: Homepage, “Code4rena is winding down” (accessed November 18, 2026)
- The Block: Zellic acquires Paradigm-backed smart contract audit platform Code4rena (August 22, 2024)
- Quantstamp: Homepage, Auditors and Public Security Assessments portal (accessed November 18, 2026)
- OtterSec: Audits, Services and Homepage (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Hashlock: Homepage and Audits (accessed November 18, 2026)
- OpenZeppelin: Security Audits and sitemap (accessed November 18, 2026)
- S&P Global: S&P Global Completes Acquisition of OpenZeppelin (October 26, 2026)
- ChainSecurity: Audit Reports (accessed November 18, 2026)
- GitHub: pashov/audits (accessed November 18, 2026)
- GitHub: Certora/SecurityReports (accessed November 18, 2026)
- GitHub: Cyfrin/cyfrin-audit-reports, report summaries (commit of October 30, 2026)
- GitHub: sherlock-protocol/sherlock-reports (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Sherlock: Homepage and audit contests list (accessed November 18, 2026)
- GitHub: trailofbits/publications, security reviews index (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Trail of Bits: Services and Application Security (accessed November 18, 2026)
- CertiK: Homepage and Penetration Testing (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Hacken: Penetration testing, compliance and audit report pages (archived copies, June 25 to November 15, 2026)
- NCC Group: Blockchain Security (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Cure53: Services and published reports (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Kudelski Security: Penetration Testing and Blockchain Security (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Guardian: Blockchain Penetration Testing (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Guardian: Smart Contract Audit
Audit and pentest with one firm
Guardian puts two independent teams on your contracts, and its keeper, API and backend pentests can run alongside them.