We manage your security to weather the AI storm →

← Resource Hub

Crypto Custodian Risk Ratings for Vendor Risk Programs

By Ashkan KhamsehpourPublished 7 min read

Part of our guide to digital asset security for banks

Crypto Custodian Risk Ratings for Vendor Risk Programs

Quick answer. For a crypto custodian risk rating, Agio Ratings rates custodians' default risk, Thomas Murray monitors custodians and Buckingham publishes a free index. Add credit and cyber ratings, SOC 1 and SOC 2 Type 2 reports, CCSS certificates and proof of reserves, then score them yourself.

Watch: Crypto Custodian Risk Ratings for Vendor Risk Programs 1:43
Video transcript

No source we reviewed rates a crypto custodian's credit, keys, cyber posture, reserves and exit at once. Here is what exists, and how to score it yourself.

The OCC says banks may outsource crypto custody, with appropriate third-party risk management. The vendor file needs a defensible rating.

Three sources assess custodians specifically. Agio Ratings offers 12-month default probabilities. Thomas Murray monitors custodians and their dependencies. Buckingham Capital Consulting publishes a free monthly index.

Each general source answers one question. Credit ratings show ability to pay. Cyber ratings never see the vault. SOC, reserve and CCSS evidence covers a set scope or moment.

Coinbase Global's S and P issuer rating was B B minus at the end of 2025, but that rates the parent, not Coinbase Custody Trust Company.

Where no rating fits, use Guardian's proposed template. Score seven categories zero to four, weight each one, add them up and date every input.

Key management and signing carries the most, twenty-five percent of the weight. The red flag is one person or vendor who can sign alone.

Then apply hard gates. Stop or escalate if the asset-holding entity is unknown, segregation terms are missing, signing is unmapped, control evidence is not current, or exit and recovery are untested.

Read the full guide for the template and rescoring triggers, or ask Guardian about the Digital Asset Assurance Pilot at guardian.security.

Why Vendor Teams Ask

National banks and federal savings associations may outsource crypto custody. OCC Interpretive Letter 1184, dated May 7, 2025, says so, subject to appropriate third-party risk management.[1]

On July 14, 2025, the OCC, Federal Reserve and FDIC said crypto safekeeping must be run safely and soundly under existing risk principles. The statement set no new expectations.[2]

Funds are watching too. The SEC proposed new crypto custody rules for advisers and regulated funds on October 1, 2026.[3]

So the vendor file needs a rating it can defend. Our third-party risk playbook covers tiers, contracts and exit; this guide covers the rating.

Independent Ratings for Custodians

A few providers assess custodians specifically: two services offered on request and one free public index. No source we reviewed covers credit, keys, segregation, cyber posture, reserves, insurance and exit at once.[2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13]

Agio Ratings gives custodians a 12-month probability of default. Its v3 model uses 17 variables, from licensing and breach history to balance sheets and onchain flows.

Agio says it covers more than 70 exchanges and custodians.[14]

Thomas Murray says it built its digital asset custody risk service in 2021. In June 2025 it announced DACM for financial institutions, then monitoring over 40 custodian groups across five risk domains.[15]

It also watches custodians' dependencies, such as wallet providers, data centers and cloud. Its public DACM page names no grade or score; ask what output you get.

As of its November 2, 2026 update, Buckingham Capital Consulting's free index ranks 12 custodians monthly on six criteria, including published pricing and asset coverage. For funds, regulatory standing weighs 25%; no provider pays to be listed.

A CCSS certificate covers one system, not a whole company, at Level 1, 2 or 3. C4's public register lists each system, level, certification date and auditor.[16, 17]

SourceWho issues itQuestion it answers
Custodian default ratingAgio RatingsHow likely is a default within 12 months?
Custodian risk monitoringThomas Murray (DACM)What does ongoing monitoring show for custodians and their dependencies?
Public custody indexBuckingham Capital ConsultingHow do 12 custodians rank on regulation, security, insurance and segregation?
CCSS auditA CCSS auditor, with C4 certificationWhich CCSS level did the custody system reach?
Credit ratingA credit rating agencyCan this entity pay its financial obligations?
Outside-in cyber ratingVendors such as UpGuard and SecurityScorecardHow exposed is its internet-facing estate?
SOC 1 reportAn independent service auditorDo controls relevant to your financial reporting work?
SOC 2 reportAn independent service auditorDo security, availability, integrity, confidentiality and privacy controls work?
Proof of reservesThe firm, sometimes with an independent accountantDid it hold the stated assets at a snapshot?
Charter or licenseA regulatorWhose rules and supervision apply?
Fund filingsA fund issuer, filed with the SECWhat custody terms were disclosed to investors?

What Each Source Measures

The SEC describes credit ratings as views on ability to pay obligations and relative default risk.[4]

They cover credit risk only, and they are not guarantees. A strong grade says nothing about key ceremonies, wallet segregation or signing controls.

Cyber ratings watch the custodian from the internet. UpGuard scores from 0 to 950 using passive external scanning; SecurityScorecard measures from the outside in and updates daily.[6, 7]

Neither can see a vault. Read the score as hygiene for internet-facing systems, not as proof that keys or client assets are safe.

SOC reports carry the control evidence. SOC 1 covers controls relevant to your financial reporting; SOC 2 tests security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality and privacy.[5, 18]

A Type 1 report judges controls at one date. A Type 2 covers whether they operated effectively over a period, so ask for a current Type 2.[19]

Read the system description before the opinion. Key management, signing services, sub-custodians and recovery may sit outside scope unless the report names them.

Proof of reserves shows assets at a moment. Kraken lists a September 30, 2026 snapshot, where an accountant checks signed onchain addresses against client balances.[9]

OKX reports $33.87 billion across 21 assets in its 49th report. Part sits with third-party custodians.[20]

In 2023, the SEC's Chief Accountant warned that non-audit crypto assurance is less rigorous than an audit. Here is how to verify proof of reserves yourself.[8]

A charter or license shows whose rules apply and who supervises. It is evidence of legal perimeter, not a security rating.[1, 2]

Fund filings can disclose what marketing pages omit. The iShares Bitcoin Trust's 2025 10-K describes Coinbase Custody's segregated vault wallets, cold storage and external SOC attestations.[10]

Gaps No Report Covers

Each report describes its own entity, system and date, which may not match your exposure.

Credit ratings show the problem. BNY reports Aa2 from Moody's for The Bank of New York Mellon at September 30, 2026, but Aa3 for its parent corporation.[21]

Coinbase Global's S&P issuer rating was BB- at the end of 2025. That rates the parent, not Coinbase Custody Trust Company, which holds ETF assets.[10, 22]

  • Private reports: SOC reports may be confidential, so a missing public copy does not mean no report exists.
  • Omnibus balances: the iShares filing says some trading-balance assets may be held omnibus, with different insolvency risk.
  • Liability caps: the same filing cites shared insurance and a $100 million cap per cold storage address, with exceptions.
  • Cyber attribution: SecurityScorecard lists false positives and false negatives among its limits; check which domains it assigns.[7]
  • Reserve scope: a snapshot may miss liabilities, encumbrances, legal ownership and anything after the cutoff.[8, 9, 20]
  • Signing authority: none of the public sources above maps who can sign today, or shows a dated recovery test.
  • Exit: none of these sources times an asset transfer out on termination.
  • Default focus: Agio's public method does not say its default score tests key ceremonies, SOC scope or segregation.[11, 14]
  • Opinion, not fact: Thomas Murray says its assessments are opinions based on information received, with no warranty of completeness.[23]

A Custodian Rating Template

Where no rating fits, build one. This is a proposed Guardian model for custody vendors, not a regulator's scoring system.

Score each category 0 to 4 on your best evidence, multiply by its weight and divide by 4, then add the seven for a weighted total. Date every input.

Our exchange security rating methodology defines each evidence level.

CategoryWeight (%)Evidence to ask forRed flag
Legal and regulatory perimeter15Charter, segregation and insolvency termsAssets held by an unlicensed affiliate
Key management and signing25Quorum map, ceremony records, a dated recovery testOne person or vendor can sign alone
Withdrawal and transaction controls15Policy engine rules, allowlists, approval logsAny path to the signer outside policy
Segregation, reconciliation and reserves15Wallet map, reconciliation records, reserve report with liabilitiesWallets never reconciled to client ledgers
SOC, cyber and operational controls15Current SOC 1 and SOC 2 Type 2, cyber rating historyType 1 only, or signing out of scope
Resilience, sub-custody and exit10Sub-custodian list, continuity test, exit runbookSub-custodians added without notice
Incidents, insurance and contract5Incident log, policy limits and exclusions, liability capsA shared limit below your balance

Hard Gates Before Weights

A high total can hide one fatal gap. Failing any gate below stops approval or escalates it, whatever the weighted score.

  • Gate: the legal entity holding client assets is not identified.
  • Gate: segregation or insolvency terms are missing from the custody agreement.
  • Gate: signing authority cannot be mapped to named people, devices and quorums.
  • Gate: no current control evidence, such as an in-period SOC 2 Type 2 report.
  • Gate: exit and recovery have never been tested.

Keeping the Rating Current

Third-party scores and methods change. Archive each rating with its date, attributed assets, methodology version and any dispute.

Collect the evidence for each category with our vendor due diligence questionnaire.

Rescore the custodian when any of these happens:

  • A change to key or signer architecture.
  • A new or replaced sub-custodian.
  • A license restriction or enforcement action against the asset-holding entity.
  • A security incident at the custodian or a vendor it relies on.
  • A reserve report that is late, changes materially or drops liabilities.
  • An expired SOC period with no new report.
  • Changed insurance limits or liability terms.
  • A drop in the external cyber rating.
  • A failed test withdrawal or recovery exercise.

Test the Custody Controls Behind the Score

Guardian's Digital Asset Assurance Pilot reviews custody and key ceremonies, privileged controls, reserve movement and signing services across the architecture your program runs or relies on, with modules you choose.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the SEC crypto custody rule in force?

No. It is still a proposal: the Federal Register published it on October 6, 2026, and comments are due December 7, 2026. Until a final rule is adopted, score custodians against current obligations.[3]

Can a cyber rating include the custodian's own answers?

Yes, at UpGuard. It says questionnaire inputs can optionally be combined into its score. Note which version you hold, because a blended score mixes outside observation with the vendor's self-reporting.[6]

What if a custodian will not share its SOC report?

Ask for it under NDA, or for a summary of scope, period and exceptions. If you still cannot see it, record the limitation, score that category on the evidence you do hold, and escalate under the control-evidence gate.

Sources

  1. OCC: Interpretive Letter 1184: Clarification of Bank Authority Regarding Crypto-Asset Custody Services
  2. OCC, Federal Reserve Board and FDIC: Agencies Issue Joint Statement on Risk-Management Considerations For Crypto-Asset Safekeeping
  3. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission: Adviser and Regulated Fund Custody Rules; Crypto Custody Rules
  4. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission: The ABCs of Credit Ratings
  5. AICPA & CIMA: 2018 SOC 2 Description Criteria
  6. UpGuard: How Are UpGuard's Security Ratings Calculated?
  7. SecurityScorecard: A Deep Dive in Scoring Methodology
  8. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission: The Potential Pitfalls of Purported Crypto Assurance Work
  9. Kraken: Proof of Reserves
  10. SEC EDGAR: iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF Form 10-K for Fiscal Year 2025
  11. Agio Ratings: Crypto Credit Ratings: How Institutions Measure Counterparty and Asset Risk
  12. Thomas Murray: Digital Asset Custodian Monitoring
  13. Buckingham Capital Consulting: The Buckingham Capital Consulting Crypto Custody Index
  14. Agio Ratings: Banks
  15. Thomas Murray: Thomas Murray Launches Digital Asset Custodian Risk Monitoring Service for Financial Institutions
  16. CryptoCurrency Certification Consortium (C4): Cryptocurrency Security Standard
  17. CryptoCurrency Certification Consortium (C4): CCSS Certified Systems
  18. AICPA & CIMA: SOC 1: SOC for Service Organizations: ICFR
  19. AICPA & CIMA: Maintaining High Standards for SOC Engagements
  20. OKX: Proof of Reserves
  21. SEC EDGAR: The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation Form 10-Q for Quarter Ended September 30, 2026
  22. SEC EDGAR: Coinbase Global, Inc. Form 10-K for Fiscal Year 2025
  23. Thomas Murray: Disclaimers
  24. Guardian: Crypto Custody: How It Works and How to Choose a Custodian
  25. Guardian: Crypto Exchange Security Rating Methodology
  26. Guardian: Third-Party Risk Management for Crypto: A Bank Playbook
  27. Guardian: Digital Asset Vendor Due Diligence Questionnaire
  28. Guardian: Best Crypto Custodians in 2026: Custody Services Compared
  29. Guardian: Bitcoin Custody: How It Works and How Institutions Hold BTC
  30. Guardian: Crypto as a Service for Banks
  31. Guardian: Crypto Compliance Manual Template
  32. Guardian: Ethena PSM Adapter
  33. Guardian: Ethena Onchain Minting
  34. Guardian: Mysten Labs suiUSDe
  35. Guardian: Jupiter JupUSD Stablecoin
  36. Guardian: Universal Hook Contracts
  37. Guardian: Ethena Onchain Minter
  38. Guardian: Peapods Finance Leveraged Volatility Farming
  39. Guardian: Ambit Finance Borrowing and Lending Platform
  40. Thomas Murray: Thomas Murray's Risk Committee
  41. Agio Ratings: Ratings | Agio Ratings Platform Features
  42. Agio Ratings: Terms & Conditions
  43. Thomas Murray: Global Custodian Monitoring